Nathaniel's Nutmeg - Giles Milton
Not raring to get my teeth into this one to be honest - it's a bit too similar to his Samurai William book - late Elizabethan/early Jacobean period, male mariners-explorers-merchants, establishing trade with the East... Not difficult to read, just a bit too dry / familiar in terms of subject matter, especially after Allison Pearson!
Basically it's the history of the spice trade, the East India Company and mapping of modern day South East Asia, in particular Indonesia and the Phillipines, and draws upon diaries and documents of the time.
I've started to I'll finish. I just hope Battersea Library re-opens soon so that I can get some more varied books out on loan....
...21 July.... FInished it on the train back from Bristol!
Another of Giles Milton's history tales, but again with a slightly misleading title. This narrative contains only one chapter on Nathaniel Courthope, and what little there is reads awkwardly, the facts not living up to the hype of the book's title and Giles Milton's interpretation. With analysis and fact coming from much of the same material as was used in Samurai William, the resulting parallels in the defects of both books shouldn't surprise. However they do disappoint; and I can't see myself buying or borrowing Big Chief Elizabeth.
Buy it: Amazon link
Tags:
4 Comments
Leave a comment
Tag Cloud
- Ahdaf Soueif
- Alan Furst
- Alan Hollinghurst
- Alev Lytle Croutier
- Alexander McCall Smith
- Alexandra Fuller
- Ali Smith
- Alistair Cook
- Allan Massie
- Allison Pearson
- Alma Alexander
- Amitav Ghosh
- Anchee Min
- Andre Maurois
- Andrea Barrett
- Andrea Levy
- Andrew Collins
- Andrew Eames
- Andrew O'Hagan
- Andrew Taylor
- Anita Brookner
- Anna Maxted
- Anne Fine
- Anne Tyler
- Annie Sanders
- Anonymous
- Asne Seierstad
- Barbara Kingsolver
- Ben Cohen
- Bernard Cornwell
- Brian Keenan
- C. J. Sansom
- Carlos Ruiz Zafon
- Charles Howard-Bury
- Charlotte Bacon
- Charlotte Bingham
- Chris Bird
- Chris Manby
- Christian Tyler
- Christiane Bird
- Christie Dickason
- Christopher de Bellaigue
- Christopher Kremmer
- Christopher Tilghman
- Colin Thubron
- Colm Toibin
- Conn Iggulden
- Cormac McCarthy
- Dan Brown
- Dan Cruickshank
- David Borgenich
- David Ebershoff
- David Liss
- David Malouf
- David Mitchell
- David Nicholls
- David Oliver Relin
- David Vincent
- Dea Birkett
- Dervla Murphy
- Diane Johnson
- Don George
- Donna Leon
- Donna Tartt
- Douglas Coupland
- Edmund Cooper
- Elizabeth Chadwick
- Elizabeth H Winthrop
- Elizabeth Knox
- Elizabeth Noble
- Eric Newby
- Fiona Walker
- Freya Stark
- Gavin Menzies
- Gavin Young
- Giles Milton
- Greg Mortenson
- Gregory David Roberts
- Helen Dunmore
- Henning Mankell
- Henry Hemming
- Ian Marchant
- Ian Rankin
- Imogen Edwards-Jones
- Isaac Asimov
- James Runcie
- Jan Guillou
- Jane Green
- Jason Burke
- Jason Elliot
- Jean-Christophe Rufin
- Jed Rubenfeld
- Jennifer Donnelly
- Jennifer Worick
- Jerry Greenfield
- Jessica Adams
- Joanne Harris
- John Banville
- John Noble Wilford
- John Sergeant
- John Simpson
- Jonny Bealby
- Joshua Piven
- Julia Gregson
- Justin Hill
- Kate Adie
- Kate Atkinson
- Kate Grenville
- Kate Morton
- Kate Mosse
- Katherine Bucknell
- Katherine McMahon
- Kathleen Jamie
- Kathy Reichs
- Khaled Hosseini
- Kim Stanley Robinson
- Kiran Desai
- Kunal Basu
- Lauren Weisberger
- Lisa Jewell
- Liu Hong
- Liza Picard
- Louisa Waugh
- Louise Tondeur
- M M Kaye
- Ma Jian
- Magdalen Nabb
- Maggie O'Farrell
- Marjane Satrapi
- Mark Shand
- Mark Tully
- Martin Davies
- Matt Barrett
- Matthew Kneale
- Melissa Bank
- Michael Connelly
- Michael Cox
- Michael Dibdin
- Michel Faber
- Mike Gayle
- Miles Harvey
- Mineko Iwasaki
- Monica Whitlock
- Neal Ascherson
- Nevil Shute
- Nicholas Jubber
- Nick Hornsby
- Nicole Krauss
- Pat Barker
- Patricia Cornwell
- Patrick O'Brian
- Paul Morley
- Paul Theroux
- Paulo Coelho
- Penelope Lively
- Peter Ackroyd
- Peter Fleming
- Peter Hoeg
- Peter Rippon
- Philip Hensher
- Philip Marsden
- Philip Pullman
- Philippa Gregory
- Piers Morgan
- Rachel DeWoskin
- Rande Brown
- Raymond Khoury
- Richard E. Grant
- Richard Loseby
- Richard Rayner
- Richard Scarry
- Robert Byron
- Ronald van de Krol
- Rory Stewart
- Rose Tremain
- Ruchir Joshi
- Ruth Rendell
- Sadie Jones
- Salley Vickers
- Sally Beauman
- Sandy Balfour
- Sara Banerji
- Sarah Bryant
- Sarah Dunant
- Sarah Waters
- Scott Berry
- Simon Garfield
- Simon Winchester
- Sophie Kinsella
- Stanley Stewart
- Stieg Larsson
- Sue Grafton
- Susan Howatch
- Tash Aw
- Ted Simon
- Tim Mackintosh-Smith
- Tim Pears
- Tim Winton
- Tony Parsons
- Tony Wheeler
- Tracy Chevalier
- Ulfat Idilbi
- Ursula LeGuin
- Val McDermid
- Vanora Bennett
- Various
- Victoria Hislop
- Ward Moore
- Wendy Holden
- Will Davenport
- William Dalrymple
- William Gibson
- William Goldman
- Xinran
- Yann Martel
- Zoe Heller
Search
Recent Posts
- Emperor: The Gates of Rome - Conn Iggulden
- Burning Bright - Helen Dunmore
- The Spirit Wrestlers: A Russian Odyssey - Philip Marsden
- The 19th Wife - David Ebershoff
- Death of a Dutchman - Magdalen Nabb
- Death of an Englishman - Magdalen Nabb
- The Girl Who Kicked the Hornets' Nest - Stieg Larsson
- Queen of Silks - Vanora Bennett
- The Hall of a Thousand Columns - Tim Mackintosh-Smith
- Mountains of Heaven: Travel in the Tian Shan Mountains, 1913 - Charles Howard-Bury, edited by Marian Keaney
February 2010
| Sun | Mon | Tue | Wed | Thu | Fri | Sat |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | |
| 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 |
| 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 | 18 | 19 | 20 |
| 21 | 22 | 23 | 24 | 25 | 26 | 27 |
| 28 |
Archives
Categories
Most read authors
- Sue Grafton (19)
- Bernard Cornwell (15)
- Patricia Cornwell (13)
- Donna Leon (11)
- Elizabeth Chadwick (11)
- Michael Connelly (10)
- Alexander McCall Smith (9)
- Michael Dibdin (8)
- Ian Rankin (7)
- Jane Green (7)
I'm reading Nathaniel's
Nutmeg for book discussion training
& can't find any biographical information
on him.
Any help would be greatly appreciated.
Thanks.
I have to read Nathaniel's Nutmeg as one of my summer reading books, and myself as well as about 50 of my peers all agree it is one of the worst books ever written. It is boring, confusing, plotless, and an outright waste of time!
Good on ya Liz.
Nice job of helping John out. Makes your email a bit of an "outright waste of time" too. :)
50 of you peers think it's one of the worst books ever written? hmmm you must have a LOT of VERY well read peers then.
Anywho - John - I am having similiar problems. I was able to find a list of other books he was written, but that doesn't really help. I found a pretty good review here which does talk of some of the problems with the book.
http://www.jmr.nmm.ac.uk/site/request/setTemplate:singlecontent/contentTypeA/conJmrBookReview/contentId/17
help me im reqaly bored with this nutmeg book...i t starts interesting..but after 70 pages i want to commit suicide!!!