1421:The Year China Discovered the World - Gavin Menzies
This is almost a non-fiction parallel to Kim Stanley Robinson's The Years of Rice and Salt, with Gavin MacKenzie setting out his thesis that between 1421 and 1423 various elements of a huge Chinese fleet discovered and mapped the Pacific Islands and Australia, North and South America, the Antarctic, Greenland and Iceland, and not forgetting the northern coast of Scandinavia and Russia, settling some and spreading flora and fauna, language, customs and technology to the others.
It's an ambitous and seductive work, drawing upon seemingly incontrovertible evidence (in Menzies' view) combined with the author's wealth of experience of times and tides gained from his career in the British Navy. Parts of me want to believe that a more culturally and technologically advanced people discovered the world before Columbus and Cook and to re-write the history of the age of European Empires, but the historian in me winced many-a-time at the huge leaps of faith required, and my gut feeling is that once I've finished I'm going to have to seek out the reactions of some professional historians to read the counter-arguments.
Ah, look at these.....
Buy it: Amazon link
Tags:
3 Comments
Leave a comment
Tag Cloud
- Ahdaf Soueif
- Alan Furst
- Alan Hollinghurst
- Alev Lytle Croutier
- Alexander McCall Smith
- Alexandra Fuller
- Ali Smith
- Alistair Cook
- Allan Massie
- Allison Pearson
- Alma Alexander
- Anchee Min
- Andre Maurois
- Andrea Barrett
- Andrea Levy
- Andrew Collins
- Andrew Eames
- Andrew O'Hagan
- Andrew Taylor
- Anita Brookner
- Anna Maxted
- Anne Tyler
- Annie Sanders
- Anonymous
- Asne Seierstad
- Barbara Kingsolver
- Ben Cohen
- Bernard Cornwell
- Brian Keenan
- Carlos Ruiz Zafon
- Chris Bird
- Chris Manby
- Christian Tyler
- Christiane Bird
- Christopher Kremmer
- Christopher Tilghman
- Colin Thubron
- Colm Toibin
- Dan Brown
- David Borgenich
- David Liss
- David Malouf
- David Mitchell
- David Nicholls
- Dea Birkett
- Dervla Murphy
- Diane Johnson
- Don George
- Donna Leon
- Donna Tartt
- Douglas Coupland
- Edmund Cooper
- Elizabeth Chadwick
- Elizabeth Knox
- Elizabeth Noble
- Eric Newby
- Fiona Walker
- Freya Stark
- Gavin Menzies
- Gavin Young
- Giles Milton
- Helen Dunmore
- Henry Hemming
- Ian Marchant
- Imogen Edwards-Jones
- Isaac Asimov
- James Runcie
- Jan Guillou
- Jane Green
- Jason Elliot
- Jean-Christophe Rufin
- Jed Rubenfeld
- Jennifer Worick
- Jerry Greenfield
- Jessica Adams
- Joanne Harris
- John Noble Wilford
- John Sergeant
- John Simpson
- Jonny Bealby
- Joshua Piven
- Justin Hill
- Kate Adie
- Kate Grenville
- Kate Morton
- Kate Mosse
- Katherine McMahon
- Kim Stanley Robinson
- Kiran Desai
- Kunal Basu
- Lauren Weisberger
- Lisa Jewell
- Liu Hong
- Liza Picard
- Louisa Waugh
- Louise Tondeur
- Ma Jian
- Magdalen Nabb
- Maggie O'Farrell
- Marjane Satrapi
- Mark Shand
- Mark Tully
- Matt Barrett
- Matthew Kneale
- Michael Connelly
- Michael Dibdin
- Michel Faber
- Mike Gayle
- Mineko Iwasaki
- Monica Whitlock
- Neal Ascherson
- Nevil Shute
- Nicholas Jubber
- Nick Hornsby
- Nicole Krauss
- Pat Barker
- Patricia Cornwell
- Paul Morley
- Paul Theroux
- Paulo Coelho
- Peter Ackroyd
- Peter Rippon
- Philip Hensher
- Philip Pullman
- Philippa Gregory
- Piers Morgan
- Rachel DeWoskin
- Rande Brown
- Raymond Khoury
- Richard E. Grant
- Richard Loseby
- Richard Rayner
- Richard Scarry
- Robert Byron
- Rory Stewart
- Rose Tremain
- Ruchir Joshi
- Ruth Rendell
- Salley Vickers
- Sandy Balfour
- Sara Banerji
- Sarah Bryant
- Sarah Dunant
- Sarah Waters
- Simon Garfield
- Simon Winchester
- Sophie Kinsella
- Stanley Stewart
- Sue Grafton
- Susan Howatch
- Tash Aw
- Ted Simon
- Tim Mackintosh-Smith
- Tim Pears
- Tim Winton
- Tony Wheeler
- Tracy Chevalier
- Ulfat Idilbi
- Ursula LeGuin
- Various
- Victoria Hislop
- Ward Moore
- Wendy Holden
- Will Davenport
- William Dalrymple
- William Gibson
- William Goldman
- Xinran
- Yann Martel
- Zoe Heller
Search
Recent Posts
- Sharpe's Havoc - Bernard Cornwell
- Tales from Nowhere - Don George (Ed)
- The Rose of Sebastopol - Katherine McMahon
- City of Bones - Michael Connelly
- Shadows and Strongholds - Elizabeth Chadwick
- The Inheritance of Loss - Kiran Desai
- The Palace of Tears - Alev Lytle Croutier
- End Games - Michael Dibdin
- Shields of Pride - Elizabeth Chadwick
- The House at Riverton - Kate Morton
May 2008
| Sun | Mon | Tue | Wed | Thu | Fri | Sat |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 2 | 3 | ||||
| 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 |
| 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 |
| 18 | 19 | 20 | 21 | 22 | 23 | 24 |
| 25 | 26 | 27 | 28 | 29 | 30 | 31 |
Archives
Categories
Most read authors
- Sue Grafton (19)
- Patricia Cornwell (12)
- Elizabeth Chadwick (10)
- Michael Dibdin (8)
- Alexander McCall Smith (7)
- Michael Connelly (7)
- Jane Green (6)
- Philippa Gregory (6)
- Tim Winton (6)
- Fiona Walker (5)
To me, it is not historians who must be the final arbiter of Gavin Menzies' theory, anymore than they should be enlisted to validate the theory of Evolution. Accepted history is just that, so it's unlikey to be changed by those who's livelihood relies on perpetuating it. A new theory is being put forward, involving the application of ideas that have simply never been in the minds of historians, nor could be, since they come from a different area of expertise. Menzies is not claiming to be a historian, so historians cannot be his judges. We need to hear from Archaeologists, botanists, Astronomers, navigators...
Thank;
I need one mail or address of the mr. Gavin Menzies for send some notes.
Dear Cesar,
Kindly write to Gavin Menzies. His email is menzies@clara.net. He'll be glad to hear from you.
Frank from Hong Kong